The debate over who deserves to represent Abuja South Federal Constituency in the House of Representatives has taken an ideological turn following a criticism by Sanusi Idris, who questioned the competence and political credentials of Kamal, the National Democratic Congress (NDC) candidate, and challenged him to demonstrate his capacity for leadership before seeking a higher public office.

Idris reportedly argued that Kamal’s previous experience as secretary of Abaji Area Council, during the period when Ajiya, the current representative of Abuja South, served as council chairman, should invite serious public scrutiny. According to him, the central question is not whether Kamal has the constitutional right to contest an election, but whether his record in public service demonstrates the competence, vision and accountability required to represent a constituency as diverse as Abuja South.

“What significant achievements can Kamal point to in Abaji from his time as council secretary? What policies did he help implement, what institutional improvements did he contribute to, and what measurable benefits can the people identify with his service?” These are the questions Idris’s criticism raises for voters to consider.

The argument goes beyond party politics. It touches on a fundamental principle of democratic leadership: political ambition should be accompanied by a demonstrable record of public service.

A seat in the House of Representatives is not a reward for political loyalty, personal relationships or the ability to mobilise influential figures. It is a constitutional responsibility involving lawmaking, oversight of government institutions, budget scrutiny, constituency representation and advocacy for the needs of ordinary citizens.

For Idris, Kamal must explain what he achieved in his previous public office before asking voters to entrust him with a greater responsibility. He suggested that aspiring to become a federal legislator without a clearly articulated record of performance raises legitimate questions about preparedness for the demands of the office.

He further challenged Kamal to consider starting with a local government chairmanship contest, arguing that such an opportunity would allow him to present a practical programme of governance, demonstrate administrative competence and establish a record that citizens could evaluate.

However, the ideological question is whether public office should be treated as a ladder for political advancement or as a platform for measurable social transformation. A responsible democracy requires leaders to account for what they have done, what they failed to do and what they intend to change.

Idris also criticised political figures he described as supporters misleading Kamal about his electoral prospects, specifically mentioning Abu Giri and others whom he accused of having disappointing leadership records.

He argued that politicians who have held positions of influence should be judged by their own public records rather than the political networks they command. In his view, the endorsement of established political figures cannot substitute for evidence of competence, integrity and tangible achievements.

The criticism raises an important issue in Abuja South politics: should candidates be assessed primarily through their alliances with influential political actors, or should voters demand evidence of what those alliances have delivered to their communities?

Political alliances are not inherently wrong. They can help candidates build coalitions, mobilise resources and develop policy support. The problem arises when political connections become a substitute for public accountability, allowing individuals to market themselves through the influence of others rather than through their own achievements.

For communities in Abaji, Kwali, Gwagwalada and other parts of the wider FCT political landscape, the standard should be straightforward: what has changed for ordinary people?

Have public institutions become more effective? Have communities gained improved access to healthcare, education, roads, water and economic opportunities? Have elected officials strengthened accountability and addressed the needs of vulnerable residents?

These are the questions that should define electoral debate, rather than personality clashes and political rivalries.

The House of Representatives is not a training centre for political aspirants who have yet to establish a clear record of public administration. It is an institution whose members are expected to understand legislative procedure, scrutinise public expenditure, engage with ministries and agencies, and translate the needs of their constituents into effective policy and oversight.

That does not mean a former council secretary is automatically unqualified to become a federal legislator. Nigeria’s democratic system does not require every candidate to have served as a local government chairman before contesting for the National Assembly. Nor does holding a previous office automatically establish either competence or incompetence.

Rather, the relevant question is what a candidate learned, accomplished and contributed while in public service.

If Kamal believes his experience as Abaji Area Council secretary has prepared him for federal representation, he should present the evidence: projects he helped facilitate, administrative reforms he supported, challenges he addressed and lessons he intends to apply at the national level.

Likewise, those criticising his candidacy should be prepared to substantiate their claims with verifiable records. Descriptions such as “corrupt,” “incompetent” or “failure” are serious political judgments that require evidence, not merely repetition during a campaign.

The same standard must apply to Abu Giri, Ajiya and every other political figure whose record becomes part of the debate.

At its core, this controversy represents a choice between personality-driven politics and performance-driven democracy.

Personality-driven politics asks voters to support a candidate because of who stands behind him, which political camp he belongs to or which powerful figures have endorsed him.

Performance-driven democracy asks different questions: What is the candidate’s programme? What has he achieved? How will he use public resources responsibly? How will he represent communities beyond his immediate political base? What mechanisms will allow citizens to hold him accountable?

From a social-democratic and public-interest perspective, political leadership should be measured by its contribution to the welfare of the people, particularly those who have historically received inadequate public services. Representation should not become an arrangement in which political elites exchange influence while ordinary citizens remain burdened by poor infrastructure, unemployment, weak public institutions and limited opportunities.

Abuja South deserves a representative who understands that legislative power is a public trust, not a personal trophy. Voters should demand credible plans for education, healthcare, agriculture, youth employment, rural development and effective oversight of public expenditure.

They should also demand transparency about how candidates intend to pursue these objectives and how their performance will be assessed.

Sanusi Idris’s criticism ultimately places a challenge before Kamal and the political figures supporting his ambition: demonstrate the record, explain the achievements and present a credible vision for Abuja South.

If Kamal believes his experience in Abaji prepared him for the National Assembly, he should defend that record publicly. If his supporters believe he represents a better alternative, they should explain why, using verifiable evidence rather than political slogans.

Similarly, Abu Giri and other experienced political actors should be willing to defend their own records against public scrutiny. No political figure should be immune from accountability simply because of past influence, party connections or an ability to mobilise supporters.

For voters, the task is not to accept Idris’s assessment without question, but to examine the evidence and compare the records, programmes and integrity of all available candidates.

The ultimate test is not who can generate the loudest controversy or assemble the most influential political supporters. It is who can demonstrate the competence, character and commitment required to improve the lives of the people.

Abuja South needs representation built on evidence, accountability and public service—not ambition without answers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *